Save to My Latticework unsave

Functional Fixedness
Functional Fixedness
Functional Fixedness
save0 saved view10.9K views
Share this with your network
Share this with your network
Overview

Things were better when you were 5-years-old. 

According to the research, that’s the age when you most use ...

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Quod cum ille dixisset et satis disputatum videretur, in oppidum ad Pomponium perreximus omnes. Minime vero, inquit ille, consentit. Duo Reges: constructio interrete. Quid ergo aliud intellegetur nisi uti ne quae pars naturae neglegatur? Callipho ad virtutem nihil adiunxit nisi voluptatem, Diodorus vacuitatem doloris. Torquatus, is qui consul cum Cn. Et harum quidem rerum facilis est et expedita distinctio.

Hanc ergo intuens debet institutum illud quasi signum absolvere. Quaeque de virtutibus dicta sunt, quem ad modum eae semper voluptatibus inhaererent, eadem de amicitia dicenda sunt. Quis, quaeso, illum negat et bonum virum et comem et humanum fuisse? Piso igitur hoc modo, vir optimus tuique, ut scis, amantissimus. Ipse Epicurus fortasse redderet, ut Sextus Peducaeus, Sex. Quid de Platone aut de Democrito loquar?

Quae cum magnifice primo dici viderentur, considerata minus probabantur. Contineo me ab exemplis. Isto modo ne improbos quidem, si essent boni viri. Nunc agendum est subtilius. In qua si nihil est praeter rationem, sit in una virtute finis bonorum; Aufert enim sensus actionemque tollit omnem. Zenonem roges; Quid autem habent admirationis, cum prope accesseris? Nam cui proposito sit conservatio sui, necesse est huic partes quoque sui caras suo genere laudabiles.

Share this model with your network to be smarter, faster, together!
Actionable Takeaways
  • Seperate the task from the solution. 

It’s all too ...

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Quod ea non occurrentia fingunt, vincunt Aristonem; Si verbum sequimur, primum longius verbum praepositum quam bonum. Si qua in iis corrigere voluit, deteriora fecit. Ut non sine causa ex iis memoriae ducta sit disciplina. Quod non faceret, si in voluptate summum bonum poneret. Sed ego in hoc resisto; Utilitatis causa amicitia est quaesita.

Duo Reges: constructio interrete. Qui ita affectus, beatum esse numquam probabis; Res enim fortasse verae, certe graves, non ita tractantur, ut debent, sed aliquanto minutius. Mene ergo et Triarium dignos existimas, apud quos turpiter loquare? Iam illud quale tandem est, bona praeterita non effluere sapienti, mala meminisse non oportere? Mihi enim satis est, ipsis non satis. Aeque enim contingit omnibus fidibus, ut incontentae sint. Quae cum ita sint, effectum est nihil esse malum, quod turpe non sit.

Qua tu etiam inprudens utebare non numquam. Illud dico, ea, quae dicat, praeclare inter se cohaerere.

Limitations

There are few substantial critiques of Functional Fixedness and it is a reasonably accepted heuristic. There have been some debates on nuances — for example, one study claiming that monetary incentives made Functional Fixedness worse, with another unable to repeat that result. But I was unable to find any studies that deny its existence or impact. 

Indeed, variations on the Candle Problem persist — with a written version delivered at Stanford University resulting in similar results.

Functional Fixedness was even put to the test with non-industrialised societies to determine the impact of cultural factors — with a recent study conducted within the Amazon region of Ecuador to compare with industrial culture. The results seemed to demonstrate that Functional Fixedness is culture blind and not related to the level of industrialisation or technology of a society. 

In Practice

Adapting during coronavirus. 

Much of our world changed during 2020. Many people were left with redundant buildings or businesses that relied on pre-Covid conditions and practices. 

Meanwhile, some companies broke through Functional Fixedness to reinvent themselves. A wonderful example of this was the Rubbens gin distillery in Belgium which moved quickly, redirecting its production of alcohol to produce disinfectant by March 2020. Other distilleries around the world soon followed suit. 

Breaking Functional Fixedness in tech startups. 

About a decade ago Canadian billionaire Daniel Butterfield, was trying to launch an online game called Glitch. Ever heard of it? Me neither. 

At the time the team created an internal messaging system to coordinate their work on the game. It was a little while in before they realised that the messaging system had more value than the game itself — and so Slack was launched. 

The Candle Problem.

This model is still best described through Duncker’s original Candle Problem from 1945. In the experiment, participants were given the following objects: 

  • A box of thumbnails

  • Matches

  • A candle

They were then asked to attach the candle to the wall while ensuring that wax would not drip on the table below once lit. The clock is ticking, how would you solve this problem? Pause for a moment and consider what you would do.

You might try pinning the candle directly to the wall or melting the candle to stick it to the wall. Both would leave the table covered in wax as the candle burnt down. A small proportion of people discovered the real solution. 

Meanwhile, another group of participants were given the same task, but were given the following objects: 

  • A box

  • Thumbnails

  • Matches

  • A candle

For those playing at home, you’ll notice that the object list is identical to the first one — only this time the thumbnails were not placed in the box.

This subtle change made the ‘box’ an object in itself and a potential part of the solution rather than just a container for thumbnails. It broke the Functional Fixedness related to, dare I say it, ‘in the box thinking.’

This slight tweak resulted in almost all participants solving the problem — simply pinning the box to the wall and placing the candle inside it. 

Angels on a pin. 

Angels on a Pin is a 1959 essay by American academic test designer Alexander Calandra describing a case where a colleague was about to give a student zero to a Physics question. The question was ‘Show how it is possible to determine the height of a building with the aid of a barometer.'

The student's answer was to tie the barometer to a rope, lower the rope and measure the resulting distance. Technically correct, but not the physics assessment they were looking for. 

The academics decided to give the student another chance, asking them to demonstrate knowledge of physics in their next attempt. The student’s second answer was to drop the barometer from the top of the roof and time how long it took to hit the ground, then use the formula S = 0.5at squared to calculate the height. 

The student was able to offer several other options including measuring the barometer versus building shadows, creating a pendulum with the barometer and comparing gravity at the different heights, or offer the barometer to the superintendent if he revealed the height of the building. 

All of the answers continued to expose the Functional Fixedness of the academics who crafted the original question. 

Build your latticework
This model will help you to:

d

Origins & Resources

The term Functional Fixedness was coined by Karl Duncker in 1945, who described it as a “mental block against using an object in a new way that is required to solve a problem.” His original study involved the Candle Problem, outlined in the overview above. 

This Candle Problem, in many ways, has become a de facto test of creative insights, leading to the 2009 study by William Maddux and Adam Galinsky to assess the impact of travelling and living overseas on creativity — they concluded that a period spent adjusting to living (not just travelling) abroad did increase creativity.

My Notes

    Nothing here yet. Join ModelThinkers and login to be the first to comment.
Already a ModelThinkers member? Please log in here.

Oops, That’s Members’ Only!

Fortunately, it only costs US$5/month to Join ModelThinkers and access everything so that you can rapidly discover, learn, and apply the world’s most powerful ideas.

ModelThinkers membership at a glance:

Small mark
UNLOCK EVERYTHING
Access all mental models and premium content.
Small mark
BUILD YOUR LATTICEWORK
Save models to your personal list.
Small mark
QUICKLY MEMORISE MODELS
Use our Learn function to embed models to memory
Small mark
PERSONALISE MODELS
Add your own notes and reminders.
Small mark
BUILD YOUR ‘EXTERNAL BRAIN’
Discover a new idea? Capture it by adding a new model.
Small mark
JOIN THE MT COMMUNITY
Rate models, comment and access exclusive events.

“Yeah, we hate pop ups too. But we wanted to let you know that, with ModelThinkers, we’re making it easier for you to adapt, innovate and create value. We hope you’ll join us and the growing community of ModelThinkers today.”

Arun Pradhan & Shai Desai
CoFounders, ModelThinkers.

You Might Also Like:

- Actionable summaries of the world's most powerful ideas.